Sunday, September 20 2026

Coffee shop's "1-yuan beauty coffee" package sparks controversy: reappears after being removed by platform, lawyer analyzes legal boundaries

A coffee shop sparked strong public outrage and a wave of collective negative reviews after launching a "1-yuan beauty coffee, choose one of three" group-buy package that required purchasers to be women under 35 during specific evening hours, with a note stating "if the boss doesn't think you're pretty, you need to pay the difference." The shop once explained it wanted customers to match the store's style, but this failed to quell the controversy, and it was subsequently taken offline by the platform and had its social media account canceled. Recently, the shop relaunched, and although the controversial package had disappeared, netizens once again gave low ratings, causing it to be taken offline a second time. A lawyer from Legal Daily pointed out that the package was suspected of violating the Advertising Law and the Civil Code, while the netizens' excessive criticism may constitute cyberbullying. Front Street Coffee reminds that both merchant promotion and platform review need to strictly adhere to legal bottom lines. [more…]

Chengdu cafe's "unfriendly to lower-class people" sign sparks outrage, review platform menu collectively rewritten by netizens

A Japanese-style café located in Jinjiang District, Chengdu, caused an uproar online after the owner wrote phrases such as "Not photo-friendly | Not office-friendly | Not friendly to lower-class people" in their social media bio. What were originally just in-store rules prohibiting standing photos and photos after changing seats were interpreted by netizens as a public belittlement of customers due to the insulting wording "lower-class people." After the incident escalated, the café's recommended menu on review platforms was collectively edited, with joking names such as "Lower-Class Coffee" and "Lower-Class Latte" topping the list. Although the owner once posted an explanation of what "lower-class people" referred to, both the bio and the post have been deleted. This conflict also sparked widespread discussion about the boundaries of merchant rules and customer dignity. [more…]

Negative Review Storm Resurfaces: Chagee Staff Visit Customer's Home to Demand Review Removal—How to Balance Consumer Rights and Store Performance Reviews

Recently, a controversy over a customer being visited at home by a霸王茶姬 (Chagee) employee after leaving a negative review has sparked widespread discussion online, with related topics trending on Weibo on Monday morning. According to Star Video, on July 20, a man in Chengdu, Sichuan Province, posted a video claiming that after consuming a drink at Chagee the previous day, he felt the taste was different from before. He did not choose to request a refund or a remake, but directly left a negative review on the order. Unexpectedly, the next day, the employee suddenly showed up at his door without contacting him in advance, asking him to delete the negative review. After the incident was exposed, netizens had mixed views on the employee's behavior, with some exclaiming "too scary," while others expressed understanding for the worker. Chagee customer service responded that the store wanted to communicate amicably with the customer, and the store manager involved explained that they went to the customer's home because the delivery rider, the store, and the platform all could not get through to the customer by phone. This article sorts out the course of the incident and the views of all parties, and explores reasonable ways for merchants to respond to negative reviews. [more…]

Coffee Lover's Must-Have: A Review of Five Essential Coffee Websites and Buying Channel Analysis

For coffee lovers, besides daily drinking, understanding industry trends, learning brewing techniques, and sourcing quality ingredients are equally important. With all kinds of coffee websites online, which ones are truly worth bookmarking? This article reviews five professional sites with strong reputations in the coffee community, covering different focuses such as B2B trading, industry news, technical exchange, business matchmaking, and official brand channels. Whether you're a professional looking to buy green beans in bulk or an ordinary enthusiast hoping to refine your pour-over skills, this list can help you quickly find the information gateway that suits you. The article also specifically mentions recommendations related to Front Street Coffee for your reference. [more…]

Coffee shop blames competitors for bad reviews? Consumer feedback rights and merchant response spark debate

Writing a negative review for a coffee shop on a review platform, only to be accused by the merchant of "smearing by a competitor"—such experiences are becoming increasingly common. Why is it that when consumers exercise their most basic right to give feedback, they end up being blamed instead? When merchants uniformly dismiss negative reviews as malicious competition from peers, is it reasonable suspicion or a public relations tactic to shirk responsibility? Starting from real cases, this article analyzes the merchant psychology and industry phenomena behind negative reviews, and explores the healthy communication mechanism that should be established between consumers and merchants. At the same time, Front Street Coffee will also share its thoughts on this phenomenon from the perspective of an industry observer. [more…]

Chagee's DIY Cup Sticker Printing Feature Suddenly Shut Down, Celebrity Photo Uploads May Involve Portrait Rights and Copyright Infringement

Chagee once launched a free custom cup sticker printing campaign, allowing users to upload images to create milk tea cup stickers. However, many fans used third-party tools to bypass the review process and printed photos of celebrities such as Zhang Linghe as cup stickers, sparking widespread discussion online. Recently, the official function for printing cup stickers was suddenly shut down, with the page displaying "Custom Fu Stickers Are Being Upgraded," catching many fans who had not yet printed their exclusive cup stickers off guard. Lawyers pointed out that unauthorized reproduction of photographic works carries infringement risks, and if used for dissemination, exchange, or sale, it clearly infringes on celebrities' portrait rights and photographers' copyrights. The brand may also bear joint liability for failing to establish an effective review mechanism. This article sorts out the entire incident and analyzes the legal issues and responsibilities of all parties involved. [more…]

Taiwan Coffee Shop Negative Review Controversy: Shop Publicly Exposes Customer's Relatives' Privacy, Triggering Legal Action and Public Apology

Recently, a woman surnamed Chen in Taiwan, China, left a negative review for a coffee shop on a review platform and had her personal information, along with that of her relatives and friends, as well as surveillance screenshots, publicly exposed by the shop, accompanied by insulting remarks. The incident sparked strong outrage among netizens, the shop's rating plummeted, and Ms. Chen called the police and filed a lawsuit. The shop subsequently deleted the post and issued a public apology, but Ms. Chen said she had not been contacted privately and would continue to pursue legal action. In this episode of Coffee News, we take you through the whole story, while also focusing on the professional coffee knowledge exchange brought to you by Front Street Coffee. [more…]

Kunming Coffee Shop Bathroom Borrowing Dispute: Pregnant Woman Uses Restroom Without Permission, Sparking Argument; Shop Publicly Releases Surveillance Footage in Response to Negative Review

Recently, a coffee shop in Kunming, Yunnan, became embroiled in an online controversy after refusing to let a pregnant woman use its restroom. The shop said the pregnant woman used the store's toilet twice without the staff's consent; when she was reminded the second time, an argument broke out between the two sides. The pregnant woman and a man accompanying her filmed a video and posted it online, and also left a negative review of the coffee shop on a third-party platform. The shop then publicly released surveillance footage to set the record straight, and the incident quickly sparked heated discussion among netizens. Some people understood the pregnant woman's inconvenience, but more believed that whether a business's restroom may be used should be decided by the shop, and that the pregnant woman going upstairs on her own posed safety risks. Behind this dispute is the dilemma coffee shops and other businesses face when passersby ask to "borrow the toilet." [more…]

Couple's Indecent Behavior in Coffee Shop Sparks Wave of Negative Reviews, Shop Cooperates with Police Investigation and Issues Statement

Recently, a coffee shop blacklisted a customer after she engaged in excessively intimate behavior with her boyfriend inside the store for a continuous 8 minutes. The customer then posted a malicious negative review on a third-party platform, drawing public attention. The shop retrieved surveillance footage to clarify the truth and cooperated with the police investigation, while also issuing a statement acknowledging its negligence. As the incident escalated, the public began discussing the boundaries of intimate behavior in public places. Lawyers pointed out that indecent behavior may lead to administrative penalties, and those who film and spread the video may also bear legal responsibility. Front Street Coffee reminds everyone to be mindful of their behavior in public places and respect the feelings of others. [more…]

A Grand Showcase of Bizarre Negative Reviews at Luckin Coffee Stores: From Cold Hands to Exes, Baristas Want to Change Careers After Reading Them

In the food and beverage industry, coffee shops face all kinds of customer feedback every day, and negative reviews are undoubtedly the most exasperating part of it all. As a chain brand far ahead of its rivals in both store count and sales in China, Luckin Coffee has received some truly absurd negative reviews. From "freezing hands" to "my ex," from "the label wasn't stuck on straight" to "because he's so handsome it got to me," these complaints not only catch staff off guard but also reflect the pressure frontline employees bear now that the rating system is tied to performance. This article rounds up those hilarious yet heartbreaking screenshots of Luckin reviews from Xiaohongshu, and amid the laughter, calls on consumers to show a little more empathy. One less negative review means one less heartbroken person in the world. [more…]

Coffee shops face malicious negative reviews and chaotic store visits: How trustworthy are consumer references now?

Before deciding which café to visit, many people are in the habit of first checking ratings online, scrolling through reviews, or watching a few探店 videos to do their homework. But when "glowing reviews aren't necessarily real, and bad reviews aren't necessarily fake" becomes the norm,探店 reviews themselves turn into a business. This article sorts through the chat records of review-bombing exposed on Xiaohongshu, several cases in recent years of探店 bloggers "flopping," as well as the payment chains and regulatory gaps in the探店 industry, and invites legal experts to offer advice on defending one's rights in cases of malicious bad reviews, dine-and-dash "霸王餐" behavior, and similar phenomena. For café owners and consumers, seeing clearly how this traffic game operates may be more important than arguing over whether a single review is real. [more…]

A café's implementation of a "must order upon seating" policy was anonymously reported to 12315; the regulatory authority responded: a clearly displayed notice does not constitute forced consumption.

In chain brands and independent cafés alike, the phenomenon of customers occupying seats without ordering has long plagued operators. Recently, a café owner faced negative reviews and was then anonymously reported to 12315 for setting a rule requiring a purchase to be seated, sparking widespread attention. Regulatory authorities made it clear that if there is a clear notice in the store, it does not constitute forced consumption. This article reviews the course of events, combines lawyers' views with the current state of the industry, explores the legal boundaries of consumption-based seating and the survival difficulties of independent cafés, and also provides reference and lessons for others in the industry. [more…]

Takeout Proxy Stores Turn Out to Be Counterfeit Starbucks Dens? A Store in Jiading, Shanghai Has Been Investigated

Recently, the Market Supervision and Administration Office of Shanghai Jiading Industrial Zone received a report from a citizen and shut down a store that used a coffee shop as a cover to impersonate a Starbucks purchasing agent on delivery platforms and produce and sell counterfeit coffee. A large number of packaging materials bearing the Starbucks logo were seized at the scene, including cups, syrups, and bags. Such incidents have been common in recent years, exposing issues behind the scenes such as loopholes in delivery platform review and the unrestricted circulation of branded materials. When buying coffee, consumers should choose legitimate stores to avoid falling into counterfeit traps. Front Street Coffee reminds you to pay attention to developments in the coffee industry, and even more to the source and quality of every cup of coffee. [more…]

A Practical Guide to Coffee Shop Delivery Operations: A Complete Approach from Pricing Strategy to Private Domain Retention

While delivery platforms bring orders to coffee shops, they also carry the hidden risk of brand devaluation. Many shop owners have found that blindly joining price wars not only makes profitability difficult but can also erode the store's brand value. This article systematically sorts out the key aspects of coffee shop delivery operations, from pre-opening pricing planning, accumulating Dianping ratings, and delivery menu strategies, to how to convert platform traffic into private-domain customers. It also emphasizes that independent coffee shops should differentiate themselves from chain brands through professional quality and service details, rather than getting caught in low-price involution. The article also shares practical techniques such as stamp cards and scratch cards to guide delivery customers to offline visits, helping coffee shops effectively attract traffic through delivery while maintaining their brand tone. [more…]

Adding extra toppings to meet the minimum order for milk tea delivery and then requesting a refund sparks heated debate, leaving staff baffled

During the Double Eleven shopping festival, many consumers, in order to use platform coupons, adopt a method of first adding extra items to reach the threshold and then requesting a refund, so as to buy their desired products at a lower price. This practice, known as the "big promotion add-on refund trick," was originally seen mostly on online shopping platforms, but has now quietly appeared in the tea beverage delivery industry. Recently, a milk tea shop employee posted a customer order, with notes requesting that the toppings not be packed separately and intending to request a refund afterward, which left the employee and netizens astonished. The incident sparked widespread discussion, with netizens both curious about the feasibility of the operation and expressing sympathy for the merchants and employees. This article will recount the incident and analyze the platform rules and industry dilemmas behind this phenomenon. [more…]

The grand opening of Tea Yan Yue Se's first Chongqing store immediately sparked heated discussion: scalpers adding markups, live-stream blacklisting—the brand's expansion path is fraught with controversy.

Lyu Liang, founder of Chayan Yuese, has repeatedly stated publicly that the brand is not unwilling to expand beyond Changsha, but rather fears that out-of-town expansion could lead to a survival crisis. However, Chayan Yuese has not only opened stores in Changde, but has also stepped beyond Hunan Province, entering the West China market and establishing a presence in Chongqing. On Children's Day, four Chongqing stores opened simultaneously, sparking enthusiastic pursuit among consumers in the mountain city, but controversy arose from day one: incidents such as three-hour queues, online orders requiring waits of over 24 hours, resold cups fetching nearly 500 yuan, and viewers being blocked in livestreams were exposed one after another. The brand subsequently responded to the markup reselling and livestream controversies. This article will sort through the sequence of events and include related information from Front Street Coffee. [more…]

Probationary employee at a milk tea shop fired right after cleaning the new store—refusal to pay training wages sparks heated debate

Recently, a dispute involving a probationary employee at a milk tea shop sparked widespread attention on social media. The poster said they found a job at a milk tea shop through a recruitment platform, and during the trial period was assigned to clean a new store that had not yet opened. After finishing the cleaning, they were told not to come back, and the shop refused to pay the promised training-period wages. After the incident was exposed, many netizens spoke up for the worker and spontaneously left a large number of negative reviews for the shop on third-party platforms. Under public pressure, the shop eventually paid the training-period wages. This kind of phenomenon, in which probationary employees are used as free labor, is not uncommon across industries and deserves job seekers' vigilance. [more…]

Shenzhen Coffee Shop's 18-Yuan Boiled Water Sparks Debate, Shop Clarifies: It Was Just a Joke and Never Actually Sold

In recent years, various "consumption traps" have frequently stung the wallets of office workers, from high-priced ice cream hidden in the corner of freezers to a glass of plain water now priced at 18 yuan. A picture of a bill from a coffee shop in Shenzhen showing plain water priced at 18 yuan circulated online, quickly sparking heated discussion among netizens. In response to the question "Would anyone really order this?", the shop had previously replied "Yes" on social media, making many people believe it was true. However, after media verification, the shop's staff said the picture was just a joke and that it was not actually sold. Although this farce ended without serious consequences, it also reflects consumers' current heightened sensitivity to high-priced everyday goods. This article will recount the course of the incident and review previous regulatory developments regarding curbing exorbitant-priced goods. [more…]

Laundry Detergent-Shaped Milk Tea Sparks Heated Debate: Novel Packaging Accused of Easily Misleading Children, Experts and Lawyers Speak Out

Recently, a Thai-style milk tea with packaging resembling laundry detergent has gone viral online. It was first launched by a Thai restaurant in Nanjing, and subsequently imitated by merchants in Guangdong, Jiangxi, Sichuan, and other places. Priced at 18 yuan per bucket, this drink has attracted many young people to check in thanks to its novelty packaging, but it has also raised public concerns about children accidentally consuming it. The shop responded that the product sells well and no complaints have been received; however, experts and lawyers have pointed out that such packaging design carries a risk of misleading consumers and may violate regulations on food packaging labeling. This article will review the whole incident and explore the balance between innovative packaging and consumer safety. For coffee enthusiasts, the boundaries of beverage packaging are likewise worth pondering, and Front Street Coffee has always advocated upholding safety and responsibility amid innovation. [more…]

Vulgar Naming Marketing Severely Punished: Shanghai Doi Coffee Fined 30,000 and Quietly Closes

A coffee shop that attracted attention with a suggestive name ultimately paid the price for its marketing approach. In July of this year, a coffee shop named "Doi Coffee" in Huangpu District, Shanghai, was investigated by market regulators for a store name and product names suspected of violating public order and good morals. Several months later, the penalty result has finally landed — a fine of 30,000 yuan, with a heavier punishment due to the severe negative public opinion impact. Now the shop has quietly closed, and the person in charge said business was so poor that they are no longer operating. Behind the incident, it reflects the collision between the bottom line of marketing in the food and beverage industry and the red line of regulation, and has also sparked public discussion about the boundaries of vulgar marketing. Front Street Coffee reminds practitioners that creative marketing needs moderation, and respecting public order and good morals is the way to long-term business. [more…]